Dealing With A Bad Hire

Bernadette Hill

January 20, 2025

Let’s imagine a world where you missed out on Talent Tap’s last blog post, “Avoiding a Bad Hire”. Such a place would be truly scary, but let’s just say that it happened and well, you’ve ended up with a less than desirable employee.


Fear not! We’re here to help.


The light at the end of the tunnel isn’t really an on-coming train. There is good news to be had: a bad hire is just one dimension of a business. Look at it this way, there are a myriad of business decisions that can take a nose-dive and people still stuck it out. Look at “New Coke”. That stuff was terrible and while Coke took a little heat for it, they soldiered on. You’ll do the same.


Like many disaster recovery plans, the first step is to admit that you have a problem. Fall on the grenade and get it over with. Why? Numerous studies have shown that sweeping the issue under the rug is only going to result in more pain later down the line. Once you are ok with saying “I hired incorrectly” out loud, you can figure out what kind of bad hire you’re dealing with:


The “No Momentum” Hire:

1) The new person starts of strong and makes an immediate positive impact…for about six months. After that, you’ll start to have an “ok” employee who falls short of initial expectations.

The “Immediate Disaster” Hire:

2) The newbie proves to be a disaster from the get go for any number of reasons – personal baggage, rude, no respect for deadlines or time, or is just flat out dangerously incompetent. 

The “Wrong Seat On The Bus” Hire:

3) The new hire is pretty much in the wrong position in terms of competencies, experience or cultural fit. This one can be realized by both the hire and the company.


Now what? Well, that’s up to you. Let’s skip over #1 for now and move right to #2. Typical wisdom is going to tell you to sever the relationship ASAP. And typical wisdom is right. Don’t let a bad hire ruin what you’ve worked to build. Harsh, but true.


As for #3, this one is a bit interesting. It may very well not be the employee’s fault here. Sometimes things are just mismatched from day one. Take the time to sit down with him or her and work out if there is a better position, in terms of fit, within the company. These folks can turn into valuable employees if you take the time to align competencies with your needs. Also review your recruiting, onboarding and training processes. Do you need a more defined job description, screening/interviewing process and/or position scorecard? 


Onto #1 we go. This can have one of two outcomes, really. First, a conversation about expectations and goals could correct the slipping and everyone will be happy. Second, it can turn out they really just don’t want to work there anymore and in that case, it’s time for you to end it and recover what you can.


How have you all handled bad hires in the past? Any techniques that have worked out for you better than others? Please, share with us in the comments below.


Up next: What if it’s you and not them?


Share This Post!

Talent Tap Trends & Insights | Lancaster, PA

Less Career Ladder, More Emotional Support Cubicle

By by: Bernadette Hill • April 13, 2026
Hugging It Out: The Workplace Version: Version: A growing number of employees are “job hugging”— holding tightly to their current roles, not out of engagement or ambition, but out of caution. With lingering concerns about layoffs, inflation, and a competitive hiring market, many professionals are opting for stability over risk . While retention may seem like a positive on the surface, job hugging can quietly impact productivity, innovation, and team morale . Employees who feel stuck or disengaged may do just enough to meet expectations, avoiding initiative or growth opportunities. Over time, this can create cultural stagnation and missed business potential. Employers should be mindful of subtle warning signs: decreased participation, resistance to change, or a lack of long-term goal setting. Addressing this starts with open communication—understanding employee concerns and creating an environment where growth feels safe, not risky. Consider: · Investing in internal career pathing and skill development whenever possible. Create low-friction ways for employees to explore new roles, projects, or teams within the organization. · Using performance-based bonuses to reward meaningful contribution. Bonuses can re-energize employees who’ve slipped into “just enough” mode—but they need to go beyond basic output. · Tying recognition to initiative—not just output . Many job huggers meet expectations but avoid stretching. Shift recognition and rewards toward behaviors like problem-solving, cross-functional collaboration, and idea generation . When employees see that effort, curiosity, and calculated risk-taking are valued (and safe), they’re more likely to re-engage rather than retreat into minimal performance. In a time when many are playing it safe, forward-thinking companies have an opportunity to reignite motivation—and turn retention into true engagement.

The Future of Work

By Bernadette Hill • January 16, 2026
The Future of Work is Owned – Literally. The way people think about work is changing fast. Today’s workforce—especially Gen Z—want more than a paycheck. They’re looking for purpose, stability, and a real stake in what they help build. That shift is pushing more small and midsize businesses (SMBs) to rethink how ownership works. Employee ownership is emerging as a practical way to improve retention, engagement, and long-term performance—without adding unnecessary complexity. Tim Garbinsky , Communications Director at the National Center for Employee Ownership, has seen how powerful this can be. When employees understand how their work directly impacts the value of the business, ownership stops being a “culture initiative” and becomes part of everyday decision-making. So, what does employee ownership look like for SMBs? Employee Stock Ownership Plans (ESOPs) offer tax advantages and are often used by owners planning an eventual exit. Employee Ownership Trusts (EOTs) provide long-term stability with simpler administration. Direct employee ownership is flexible, cost-effective, and easier to roll out than many owners expect. Worker cooperatives emphasize shared ownership and democratic governance. Profit-sharing and equity compensation align incentives without shifting control. Tandem Business Center for Shared Success helps companies explore direct ownership models. According to Executive Director Drew Mousetis , about 40% of the businesses Tandem initially meet with, ultimately move forward—often starting with gradual employee education around stock ownership, financials, and valuation. Employee ownership tends to work best for businesses that are thinking about succession, want to compete for talent without raising payroll, and care deeply about culture and continuity. As Garbinsky notes, employees value transparency and stability far more than many leaders realize—especially during uncertain times. The takeaway:  Employee ownership is not just a perk. It’s a strategic way to strengthen your business, reward your people, and plan for the future.
More Blog Posts